Many players like Port Royale 2 because it is a deep and detailed trading game set in the 17th-century Caribbean. In the game, players trade goods between more than 60 towns, build production buildings, and grow a large trading empire. Many reviews say the trading system is flexible and fun, especially with features like automatic trade routes and convoy control. These systems are good for players who enjoy strategy and managing many details.
The game also has sandbox mode and tutorials that help new players learn step by step. At the same time, experienced players can create complex trade networks and expand their business. Players can also govern towns, interact with AI governors, and affect how the game world develops, which adds more replay value.
However, some players feel that parts of the game are frustrating. Naval battles and mini-games are often criticized because they can feel unfair or not very smooth.